Chapter Four: The Specialist
Reading Time: ~ 18 min
The air in Dr. Maren’s office carried a faint trace of sandalwood and the soft hum of the heater. On a small side table, two miniature, ceramic pumpkins added a touch of seasonal orange to otherwise muted decor. Elias sat upright this time, shoulders squared, not slouched as he had been in last session.
Five weeks since Clara’s passing. In some ways it still felt like yesterday, her presence lingering in the quiet corners of their apartment. Yet in other ways, the weeks stretched long and heavy, as though he had aged years in that short span.
He was back at work now. Back at his desk, back to the motions of emails, meetings, the drone of normal life. Yet the rhythm felt foreign, like slipping into clothes that no longer fit. Colleagues spoke to him with a softened voice, careful around his silence. He nodded, he smiled when required, but inside the hollowness persisted.
Dr. Maren leaned forward slightly in her chair, a notepad balanced on her knee. Her voice was gentle, but it carried weight. “Elias, I wanted to ask—do you have any relatives you can lean on? Anyone you might reconnect with, to help carry some of this sorrow? With the holidays starting up, these times can often feel the most isolating.”
He hesitated. The question touched an emptiness deeper than grief, a wound reopened by the cheerful autumn colors. Last Halloween had already been shadowed by Clara’s diagnosis. He hadn’t wanted to bother with decorations or the stream of children, but she had insisted on a proper celebration. They were both non-believers, but she’d looked him straight in the eye and said, “We must always fight for reasons to celebrate life, Elias. Especially now.”
He clasped his hands together, knuckles whitening, and finally met the doctor’s eyes. “My parents were both Iranian Jews,” he said, his voice slow, deliberate, as if unearthing something long buried. “They fled after the revolution. Came here with almost nothing. My grandmother came with them too. She raised me, in some ways. But she died when I was two. I don’t remember her.”
Dr. Maren nodded, scribbling something quietly.
“I don’t know if I have family back there,” Elias continued. “Iran, I mean. If they even survived, if they’re even alive. My parents never spoke of it much. They wanted to forget. To start over here.”
“And now?” she asked.
He let out a humorless laugh. “Now they’re both gone. It’s just me.”
The silence lingered, not empty but respectful. Dr. Maren set her pen down. “That must feel… bereft.”
“It does.” Elias’s eyes dropped to the rug beneath his shoes. Patterns swam and shifted. “Clara was my only real anchor. Without her, I don’t know where I stand anymore.”
Dr. Maren let that rest for a moment before steering gently. “You mentioned in our last session that you’d been having dreams more frequently. Has that continued?”
His head lifted. “Yes.”
“And the dreams themselves—have they changed?”
Elias hesitated, then said, “Yes. I’ve had these dreams since I was a boy. Always different. Always about losing someone—a face I didn’t know, a voice that faded the moment I woke. But since last week, since we spoke… it’s always her. The same woman. Every night. That has to mean something.”
Dr. Maren reflected, “Perhaps your mind has stopped scattering fragments and chosen to show you one story more clearly. Or perhaps… you are finally ready to remember.”
“Remember,” Elias whispered, his face tight with desperation.
Dr. Maren’s eyes softened. “The woman, she felt familiar?”
“Yes.” His throat tightened. He paused, then forced the words. “I don’t understand why it’s her and not Clara. But it’s not going away.”
Dr. Maren leaned back, folding her hands. “Have you done anything to explore these dreams further?”
Elias gave a faint, weary smile. “I tried. I went online. Forums, groups, places where people talk about past lives. Most of it is nonsense. People claiming they were Napoleon, Cleopatra, Marilyn Monroe. Everyone seems to have been someone famous.” He shook his head. “Nothing useful.”
Her smile was small, knowing. “The internet can be like that.”
“I thought maybe I’d find someone who’d been through what I’m going through,” Elias said, frustration edging his voice. “But all I found were people telling stories that sound like bad novels.”
Dr. Maren tapped her pen lightly against her palm, considering. “There may be another way.”
Elias’s brow furrowed. “Another way?”
“I have a friend,” she said slowly. “He’s a professor at Boston University. Religious studies, with a focus on cross-cultural beliefs in the afterlife. He’s been studying reincarnation for years. Not from the angle of sensationalism, but with academic rigor. He also hosts monthly meetups here in the city, where people who believe they’ve experienced past lives come together to share their stories.”
Elias raised an eyebrow. “Like a support group?”
“In a way. More of a community,” she said. “I’ve attended a few myself, just to listen. Some stories are wild, yes. But others… some made me pause. Made me wonder.”
Elias shifted in his chair, uncertain.
“You don’t have to believe them,” Dr. Maren added. “But sometimes, hearing others can put our own experiences in perspective. It might help you to know you’re not the only one grappling with these questions.”
He rubbed the back of his neck. “I don’t know. Sounds a little… out there.”
She smiled faintly. “Perhaps. But you came to me, Elias. Something in you is searching. Why not give it a chance?”
Her words settled over him, not heavy, not pressuring, but quietly persistent.
After a long silence, he nodded. “Alright. I’ll try.”
Dr. Maren reached for her desk and slid a card across to him. “This is his contact. Professor Aaron Feldman. He’s leading the next meetup in a few days.”
Elias took the card. The name felt ordinary enough, but the idea behind it pulsed with something strange, something that tugged at him.
The library basement carried a trace of dust and old wood. A few paper bats and faded spiderwebs still clung half-heartedly to the pipes near the ceiling. A faint thrum rose from the strip lights overhead, casting a pale glow across folding chairs arranged in a circle. A dozen, maybe fifteen people filled the seats, voices murmuring with anticipation. Some were young, some old, a mixture of faces and accents.
Elias sat near the edge, his coat draped over the back of his chair. He kept his hands folded in his lap, eyes lowered, listening.
The stories unfolded, one by one.
A middle-aged woman in a red scarf claimed she had been a nurse in World War I, tending to soldiers in the trenches. Her voice quavered with drama as she described dying in a gas attack.
A wiry young man insisted he had once been Julius Caesar. The group nodded politely, though Elias bit back a scoff.
Another man swore he had been a Viking warrior, showing off a crude tattoo he claimed marked him since birth.
Elias listened, trying to keep an open mind, but skepticism gnawed at him. Too many of the stories sounded rehearsed, embellished, performed for attention. He felt like he had stumbled into a theater groupe rather than a gathering of souls.
Still, he stayed. He waited. He listened.
But the hour dragged on, and disappointment settled like dust. His dream was different. It wasn’t grand or glorious. It wasn’t about being famous. It was always about loss and helplessness. It hurt. And sitting here, surrounded by self-proclaimed emperors and warriors, he felt like a fool.
When the meeting finally ended, chairs scraped against the floor, voices rose as people chatted in little clusters. Elias stood, shrugging on his coat, ready to leave.
He was almost at the door when a voice stopped him.
“Mr. Shirazi, isn’t it?”
Elias turned. The man approaching was in his mid-fifties, tall, with graying hair and thoughtful eyes behind thin-rimmed glasses. He wore a tweed jacket, the kind professors always seemed to own, and carried himself with quiet confidence.
“Yes,” Elias said cautiously.
The man extended a hand. “Aaron Feldman. I believe Dr. Maren told you about me?”
Elias shook his hand. “Yes. She gave me your contact.”
Feldman smiled. “I saw you listening tonight. Not speaking. That tells me you’re more serious than most.”
Elias hesitated. “I wouldn’t say that. Just… not convinced.”
“Good,” Feldman said, his eyes sharp. “Skepticism is a sign of honesty. Too many come here with stories they’ve convinced themselves of because it makes life feel grander. But you… you were listening differently.”
Elias felt a flicker of something—curiosity, maybe even hope.
“Do you have time for a coffee?” Feldman asked. “I’d like to hear your story. Not here, though. Somewhere quieter.”
Elias glanced at the exit, then back at Feldman. Something in the man’s tone carried weight, like he wasn’t offering small talk but an invitation into deeper waters.
“Yes,” Elias said finally. “I have time.”
“Good. Then allow me to lead the way,” Feldman said.
And with that, they stepped out into the night together.
Elias sat across from Professor Feldman at a corner table. The professor had insisted on the spot, half hidden by a pillar, away from the bustle. A battered notebook lay beside his cup, as if he never traveled without something to write in. His tweed jacket looked even older under the café’s dim light, but his eyes carried a sharpness that cut through the coziness.
Elias wrapped his hands around his own cup, letting the steam rise against his face. He hadn’t drunk yet. The smell of dark roast curled up to his nose, rich but slightly bitter.
“So,” Feldman said, folding his hands, “you’ve been having these dreams since you were young?”
Elias nodded. “For as long as I can remember. Childhood, adolescence… always the same pattern.”
“And the pattern is?”
Elias let out a slow breath. “Loss. It’s always loss, and the feeling of helplessness. Every time, I lose someone I don’t recognize. I can’t name them, but they feel strangely familiar, like they are part of me. When they’re gone, I don’t just watch them vanish; I watch myself fracture. And then, I wake up with the same emptiness.” The words felt heavier when spoken aloud. The café chatter blurred around them, plates clinking, an espresso machine hissing.
Feldman studied him carefully. “Did you ever have any recurring dreams?”
“Not until recently.” Elias shifted in his seat. “That’s what has changed. Since last week… it’s been the same woman, every night. The fire, the fighting. Losing her again and again.”
Feldman leaned forward slightly. “But before her, it was always different people?”
“Yes. The faces changed. Though the ending didn’t.” Elias shook his head, staring into the swirl of steam above his cup. “It’s like my dreams have finally chosen one story. Her story.”
Feldman tapped a finger against his notebook, thoughtful. “That’s important.”
“You’re going to tell me it means something. That’s what everyone in that basement said too, before they told me they used to be Napoleon.”
A dry smile touched Feldman’s mouth. “Fair enough. You’re owed some skepticism after that room. But you noticed something tonight, didn’t you? Watching them.”
“That they were performing.”
“Most of them, yes. People who want a past life the way they’d want a title. Grander than the one they have now.” Feldman turned his cup a quarter turn without drinking from it. “You didn’t want anything grand. You wanted the thing to stop. That’s the difference I’m asking you to sit with.”
“So, what now? I get a participation trophy?”
“No,” Feldman said, without any offense in it. “You get taken seriously. That’s rarer than you’d think.”
Elias didn’t say anything.
Feldman inclined his head, drawing the notebook toward himself. He opened it and flipped through pages dense with cramped handwriting. He stopped on one and turned it so Elias could see, though it told him nothing, just a column of numbers beside a set of initials, and a single underlined word—consistent.
“Fourteen years of this,” Feldman said, tapping the page. “Cases I’ve followed, some for a decade or more. Children who spoke of places they’d never been, in languages no one taught them. Adults who described the manner of a death that, when I checked the historical record, matched down to the day.” He closed the notebook again, not offering it further. “I’m not telling you this to impress you. I’m telling you so you understand I don’t take a repeating dream lightly. Most people’s dreams don’t repeat. Yours has narrowed to one woman, and it’s the only thing you’ve described tonight with your hands shaking.”
Elias glanced down. His hands were, in fact, wrapped too tightly around the cup.
“So what does that make me?” he asked. “One of your cases?”
“It makes you someone worth a second conversation,” Feldman said. “Whether you’re a case remains to be seen.”
Elias exhaled, some of the challenge going out of him. “And if I’m not? If this is just grief wearing a costume?”
“Then you’ve lost an evening to a strange old man and a mediocre coffee,” Feldman said. “There are worse ways to spend one.”
That, at least, pulled a short breath of laughter from Elias, unwilling as it was.
Feldman’s eyes flickered with something Elias couldn’t quite name—satisfaction, perhaps, or calculation. “I know someone,” he said after a moment.
Elias’s gaze snapped back to him. “Someone?”
“A specialist,” Feldman explained. “Not a professor, not a therapist. She works with people like you—not the attention-seekers. The rare ones.”
“And she could help me?”
“She could tell you whether there’s anything to help with at all,” Feldman said. “I won’t promise you more than that. And you are quite lucky—she is in the States now, in New York City, as it happens.”
Elias leaned back, the chair creaking softly. “Why me?”
Feldman’s eyes softened. “I don’t know why specific souls get handed this. I only know it doesn’t fall on people at random.”
Elias rubbed his temples. “And this specialist—what would she do?”
“Ask you the same questions I have, likely with less patience,” Feldman said. “Whether she can do more than that, I couldn’t tell you. I’ve sent her three people in fourteen years. I don’t know what became of the other two.”
“Who is she?” Elias asked.
“I’ll tell you her name,” Feldman said. “But only once you’re sure you want to make the call. Some doors don’t close again once you’ve opened them.”
Elias stared into his untouched coffee. Steam had thinned to a faint wisp. His reflection shimmered on the dark surface—tired eyes, drawn skin. Behind that reflection, a flicker of fire, a woman’s face, a scream he could never silence.
He closed his eyes. “Yes. I want to know.”
Feldman gave a small nod, as though he had expected nothing less. He reached into his jacket and slid a card across the table, just as Dr. Maren had done days before. Elias picked it up. A name. A number. No other details.
“She will be expecting you,” Feldman said quietly. “Tell her I sent you. And tell her about the woman in your dreams.”
Elias held the card, feeling its weight as though it were more than paper. It was a doorway. Perhaps even a key.
The café around them buzzed on, indifferent. But Elias knew the world had shifted again.
